Thanks for all the advice, everyone! I've been trying to work this out based on your help throughout the day, but am not making too much progress.
1) Could it be that BOTH my 60 degree blades ended up with dulled (or chipped?) tips? I looked at them both under a magnifying glass and they appear to be slightly blunted at the tips, but not much. It is impossible that they were dulled by the few times I used them ... went through the media and well into the mat a few times, but did not cut through the mats. What I think might have happened was dulling or chipping by dragging the CD under the blade ... sometimes the blade would be scratching it, especially if I wasn't pressing down on the mat and media. I found a piece of matboard that seems to be about the right height, and have started using that instead.
2) At one point, the blade picked up a bit of paper from the cutting and dragged it around. (That does have a distinctive look, and I include a picture for those who haven't seen it before.)
3) Switched out the 60 degree blades for a new 45 degree blade. I still have the same effect in the cut.
4) It's humid outside, but inside the dehumidifier is running, the windows are closed, and the air conditioner is on.
5) I've been using a Cricut mat, though I've tried a bit on the Black Cat mat (the part that's left, that is. Impatience, ready availability of a hair dryer, and well known tendency to over-do proved to be an unlucky combination when trying to get rid of a curl in the mat! [Yes, I knew better about the iron, but was at the point of no return ...
])
I generally use this Georgia Pacific cardstock for experimenting (and it worked out fine most of the time when I was using my old Craft Robo), so I am really perplexed as to why I can't manage to do this ... I think it's time for me to try a different and lighter weight cardstock. My next welded word experiment will be "Keep Calm".
Further advice is welcome!
Deborah
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.